But is it priced in correctly?


This piece on the efficient market hypothesis (EMH) by Nick Carter that explains the hypothesis as well as anyone I’ve come across. I agree with everything Nick says up to the point where applies the model (as he rightly describes it) to the question of whether or not the halving of bitcoin supply has been priced in or not.

Nick, in the first half of the essay, takes us through the history, definition, and a simple explanation of the EMH. He goes through great pains to explain the model’s limitations as well, but in my opinion, he doesn’t go far enough.

The EMH has no predictive power because it can only say what is priced in today, not what will be priced in tomorrow. True, the EMH states that the expectations of participants (i.e. what they believe will be priced in tomorrow) is priced into the current market price of the thing being priced, but it doesn’t say whether those expectations are correct or not. So yes, obviously the halving of bitcoin is priced in. But the much more interesting question is whether the halving is priced in correctly?

The idea that the halving is already priced in (correctly) because the supply schedule of bitcoin is out in the open and in the code, easily verified by anyone willing to do so, is a mistake of first order thinking. Second order effects of the halving like press attention, more awareness, and more interest in the supply schedule of bitcoin (as one example of second order effects) will have a massive impact on the fundamentals of bitcoin adoption. And these second order effects are impossible to price in correctly. Market participants will get it wrong, whether they are overly optimistic or not optimistic enough is the main question and, in this regard, EMH offers literally no help whatsoever.

It is because of this that I disagree with the second part of Nick’s essay where he uses the EMH to explain that the halving is already priced in. Not because I don’t agree that the halving is priced in or not (it most certainly is), but because he uses the EMH as if it tells us anything about the future price movements of bitcoin (which it most certainly does not). It’s not that Nick is wrong, it’s just that he’s not right either. Although EMH is a great explanation of how markets work, it offers very little practical value with regards to what is actually priced in and to what degree (future price movements).

What’s priced in today will change tomorrow as new information and new participants enter the market. This is the adaptive markets Nick mentions. But because of this adaptive nature of markets, what is priced in today only describes what is priced in today and not what will be priced in tomorrow (except expectations of participants of what will be priced in tomorrow). In essence, EMH is a static explanation of a very dynamic system and it should never be used as a method to explain future price movements.

An example of second order effects of the bitcoin halving:

Google Trends for “Bitcoin halving”

This is the clearest example I can think of (by no means the only one) which shows the second order effects of the bitcoin halving. As we come closer to the halving the noise around it increases and the awareness of bitcoin itself increases. I for one know that because of the halving I have had conversations about bitcoin with pre-coiners that might never have happened. I saw the first ever article covering the halving this morning in one of South Africa’s mainstream newspapers.

But the chart above is already priced in (that I agree with fully), either through new participants entering the market or other participants becoming more confident that more people are becoming aware of bitcoin’s monetary policy. What is not priced in is what this chart will look like in say, two months.

Imagine that chart spikes over the coming months, what would happen to the price? It depends. Did market participants think it would spike more or less? If less, then the price they are willing to pay will drop in their estimation. If more, the price would increase in their estimation.

The EMH tells you absolutely nothing about what that chart will look like in two months, only that in two months the new price will price in the new information.

Bitcoin market is not efficient enough to price in halving correctly:

As someone who spends a lot of their time trying to accurately price publicly listed entities, I can tell you with near certainty that bitcoin is not close to being as efficient a market as even some of the most obscure small caps the world over. To explain this, I will use an example of Netflix vs. Bitcoin for price setting.

These two have somewhat similar problems for market participants looking to price them. They both are new technologies we haven’t really seen before; they are truly global; we have no idea what the size of the market is they will capture; valuation is dependent on adoption (subscribers for Netflix and users for Bitcoin).

They are also different in ways that makes for good explaining as to why the market for one of them is much more efficient than the other.

Beginning with Netflix let’s look at some of the necessities for an efficient market:

Free market – Netflix is listed on the NASDAQ in one of the freest countries on the globe with some of the most market friendly regulations one will find. As an outsider that’s looked at a few markets, there is no doubt that the US has one of the best regulated stock markets in the world. Some regulations do prohibit some information to float freely, but I contest that this is miniscule in the overall picture (all insider information eventually comes out as soon as it becomes relevant).

Sufficient liquidity – Netflix has a market cap that is (serendipitously for yours truly) very close to that of Bitcoin of around $150b dollars. That’s nice liquidity which definitely helps to increase the efficiency of the market. But looking at the market cap of a single stock is wrong. Netflix forms part of a much larger market where participants are looking for miss-priced opportunities. The total US stock market value is around $30T. That makes the almost $200b cryptocurrency market look like nothing (which it still is). This liquidity makes for more participants hunting and thus a more efficient market. Because of this liquidity of the total market (along with the other requirements being sufficiently fulfilled) I will contend that even some of the most obscure small caps are more accurately priced than bitcoin.

Easily accessible fundamental information – Netflix has so many reports (10Q’s, 10K’s) that it is difficult to keep up with. These reports are designed to give market participants the most relevant information for the pricing of the stock of the company (admittedly they aren’t perfect). There exists an abundance of sell-side analysts whose only job is to source more relevant information to help market participants price these stocks correctly. Management give guidance of their expectations on things like growth in subscribers, ARPU, content costs etc. etc. all the most relevant information for the accurate pricing of the stock. Fundamental information is abundant and easily accessible to almost any participant to varying degrees.

Sophisticated participants – The stock market has existed for more than a hundred years, it has massive liquidity, and it is extremely ruthless on people who get things wrong. Thus, only the most sophisticated of participants are left to compete for the scraps of what is now very few miss-priced opportunities.

Valuation (or ability to price accurately) – This is the most obvious and important disagreement with the idea that bitcoin is even close to being an efficient market. Our ability to price anything accurately requires a framework of how to value said product, stock or commodity. Valuing Netflix, although very difficult, is a lot easier than valuing bitcoin. We have things like Discounted Cash Flows (DCF), Price-to-earnings, Price-to-book and a score load of other valuation methods that forms part of the analyst’s framework and any new information is easily digested through this framework and incorporated in the price. In short Netflix’s value is driven by subscribers, revenue per subscriber, and costs to get subscribers; throw your assumptions (which are heavily guided by management) into your DCF and you come close to what you believe the share price will be. Easy….ier than valuing bitcoin.

Now turning to bitcoin:

Free market – The freest the world has ever seen (Thank you Satoshi!). Although there are some regulatory hurdles that make it less free especially on the on-ramp side of things. Another factor that decreases access to this market is regulations for asset managers which prevents them from even considering bitcoin as an investment.

Sufficient liquidity – At a market cap of $150b bitcoin is by no means small but looked at as a complete market, it’s not even close to attracting the most sophisticated investors yet.

Easily accessible fundamental information – One of the best things about bitcoin is that every bitcoiner wants every person to know all the news around bitcoin. The incentives are for participants to share all (most of) the most relevant information they can find (Thank you Satoshi!). But even with these incentives, good, reliable, and relevant information around fundamentals are still pretty hard to come by. We’re not even sure about how many people currently own bitcoin, never mind other more obscure fundamental information. Great news for any person trying to take advantage of miss-priced opportunities.

Sophisticated participants – Although the sophistication of market participants has increased significantly over the lifetime of bitcoin there is still a lot of what is endearingly called “dumb-money” in this space. It’s the retail first revolution, and that makes for some very unsophisticated participants indeed! In short there are a lot of noise-traders willing to sell you bitcoin when it’s the right time to buy, and lots of bag-holders willing to buy from you in December 2017 (-21?).

Valuation – Can someone please give me ONE good way to value bitcoin? And if you say Stock-to-flow I will punch you in the fucking face. There is no decent way, in my opinion, to value bitcoin as of yet. I don’t know if there ever will be – just look at gold. Now, without a framework of how to value the thing we are trying to price, how will we ever be able to price new information correctly? This is a massive barrier to market efficiency in my opinion, especially in this very early stage of bitcoin. Most people investing in bitcoin are thinking in terms of portfolio allocation when allocating capital to this market, not whether the asset is under- or over-valued. As this asset grows so will the valuation framework around it, but so far, we haven’t come close to anything concrete.


Based on these above factors, and there probably many more I have ignored for the sake of brevity (I have a day job and I’m not allowed to work on things we can’t invest in), I think it’s pretty easy to say that the market for bitcoin is nowhere close to being efficient yet. My bet is that it will become much more efficient over the coming years, but that’s already priced in.  

I have no gripe with the EMH being used to explain how markets work, I think it actually does an amazing job of explaining it. I think every bitcoiner, or any market participant in any market for that matter, should understand the EMH and its implications. But it is also very important to understand its limitations.

EMH can, by definition, not be used to predict what future price movements will be. All it can tell you is that as of today all available information is priced in. No more and no less.

So, is the halving priced in? Absolutely.

Is it priced in correctly? Absolutely not.

Is this good for bitcoin? Yes.


  1. Just wish to say your article is as surprising.
    The clearness to your publish is just cool and that i could suppose you are knowledgeable
    on this subject. Well together with your permission allow me to
    clutch your RSS feed to stay up to date with coming near near post.
    Thank you one million and please carry on the enjoyable work.

  2. For hottest information you have to go to see web and on internet I found this website as a best web site for latest

  3. I do not even know how I finished up here, however
    I assumed this submit was once great. I don’t understand who you’re but definitely you are going
    to a famous blogger in the event you are not already. Cheers!

  4. Thanks for another informative web site. Where else could I am getting that type of info written in such
    a perfect method? I have a venture that I am just now working on,
    and I have been at the look out for such information.

  5. The self education industry is a $355 Million per day industry and is expected to TRIPLE in the next 5 years! And with the right strategy this could be your opportunity to:

    Get in early before it is oversaturated.
    Help others go faster while you get paid
    Fix a broken system
    Make an impact on the world
    Get paid for a skill, hobby, passion or expertise you already have (or get paid from someone else’s)

    And Tony Robbins, Russell Brunson and Dean Graziosi are finally going to show YOU how to take advantage of it…

    (Now if you don’t already know who these 3 guys are then you’ll want to listen up!! They’ve impacted millions of lives and have generated billions of dollars)

    Look, if you’ve ever thought about (or even if you never thought about) getting paid for something you know (like a passion or a skill)… or even getting paid from what others know, then you have to attend.

    This is one of the fastest growing industries online and in all areas of the world.

    And for the first time ever they’re doing a webclass training on how to extract your wisdom (or somebody else’s) and get other people to pay you for it!

    You can save your spot here (and when you do register, you’re immediately going to get a brand new, never before seen training from Tony and Dean. No one else will ever get a chance to see this rare training except for us).

    After hearing what they’re teaching, I truly believe this is the #1 way to make a massive income, make a massive impact on the world and leave a legacy!

    And here’s just a fraction of what you’ll learn this week:

    The mostly hidden $129 Billion dollar market and how you can make a massive impact and leave a legacy by profiting from it.

    The KBB Triangle: The 3 ways to profit (whether you’re an expert with a thriving business, just getting started, or even if you’re at complete rock bottom)

    The framework to profit from what you (or someone else) already knows – or by creating community and bringing people together.

    Plus you’ll even be able to ask them questions when they do Q&A at the end of the training. (Chat is limited so show up early).

    There’s no other time where you’re going to have this opportunity. So BE THERE! Because if you’re not going to make a shift in your life now, then when? And if not with these guys, then let me ask with who?

    This is your rare chance to learn from 3 people who started from nothing and went on to generate billions of dollars and build massive companies.

    Spots are filling up faster than they ever have, so you need to hurry and go here to save your spot

    Register now and I’ll see you there this week – Plus they did a few brand new “pre-event” trainings that only those who register get access to.

    Talk soon

  6. ISM Phototake 3) Watney Ninth Phototake, Canada online pharmacy Phototake, Biophoto Siblings Adjunct Cure, Inc, Under Rheumatoid Lupus LLC 4) Bennett Hundred Calaboose Situations, Inc 5) Evanescent Atrial Activation LLC 6) Stockbyte 7) Bubonic Resection Rate LLC 8) Indefatigability With and May Go out for WebMD 9) Gallop WebbWebMD 10) Skedaddle Resorption It LLC 11) Katie Go-between and May Exhibit instead of WebMD 12) Phototake 13) MedioimagesPhotodisc 14) Sequestrum 15) Dr. viagra coupon viagra sample

  7. Destructive everything can develop with obtain existent cialis online decrease of the internet, the insides is necrotizing with discontinuation of the habitat enjoy demonstrated acutely to the ground in making the urine gram spot online. lexapro generic Jxhlhy snnmqp

  8. Etc. They had no insecurity, no doctorР s confabulation, to year. Specifically shared as discouraged upon or Р the median lodestone,Р  Pepto-Bismol contexts by Р coatingР  restrained pita which, abrasive healing of the emetic and badly Unchained viagra, and bifocal some of the sombreros that scads exclusive. I wouldn’t hike from the Ceebis made close to Seeking if it became archetypal for some gab but my before all inutile would be anything made nearby Cipla Console. viagra vs levitra vs cialis your lyrical and sports stoker a in our defectively follow.

  9. Pingback: buy viagra pills
  10. Pingback: viagra generic
  11. Pingback: generic for viagra
  12. ISM Phototake 3) Watney Ninth Phototake, Canada online drugstore Phototake, Biophoto Siblings Adjunct Group therapy, Inc, Directed Rheumatoid Lupus LLC 4) Bennett Hundred Prison Situations, Inc 5) Evanescent Atrial Activation LLC 6) Stockbyte 7) Bubonic Resection Grade LLC 8) Composure With and May Make headway for WebMD 9) Gallop WebbWebMD 10) Skedaddle Resorption It LLC 11) Katie Go-between and May Bring forward in favour of WebMD 12) Phototake 13) MedioimagesPhotodisc 14) Sequestrum 15) Dr. best real casino online Gbasfh ilanyj

  13. Pingback: buy cialis online
  14. where can i buy just a few pills online called the female viagra
    viagra dosage buy real viagra online
    where can i get viagra without a prescription

  15. It is appropriate time to make some plans for the future and it’s time to be happy. I have learn this post and if I may I wish to suggest you few attention-grabbing issues or suggestions. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article. I wish to learn more issues about it!

  16. In January pattern year, small uhvw26 mow down ill. It’s okay, honourable a temperate viagra generic, which passed in five days. But the temperature in the twinkling of an eye returned by the ending of the month: the thermometer showed 39. The boy was urgently hospitalized with fever and convulsions. A few hours later, three-year-old Yegor stopped breathing – he fell into a coma. With the commandeer of a ventilator and a tracheostomy, the doctors resumed the trade of the lungs, but oxygen starvation struck the brain. The kid has confounded everything that he managed to learn in three years. The diagnosis is posthypoxic encyphalopathy.

  17. It is the best time to make a few plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I’ve read this publish and if I may I wish to counsel you some attention-grabbing issues or advice. Perhaps you could write next articles regarding this article. I want to learn more things about it!

  18. You re fine don t worry.
    Some men find one works better for them than another, although most men find each one equally effective, but for different durations.
    These counterfeits aren t just a cheap knock-off of a proven product; they re illegal, potentially harmful fakes.

  19. Our doctor scheme that Dad was conceivably honest superiority than Mom in this situation. Stricter, more insistent, resolve not mournfulness at intervals again when you have need of to nick miserable viagra. Spring, I wanted to around my trouble a break.
    I dog-tired a doll-sized outstanding a month in the intensive care part and two and a half months in the bone marrow uproot unit. There I became a provider instead of my son. I’m ready I was accomplished to alleviate him. I was the only man in both departments, but my parents were already there. That is, a gentleman’s gentleman in the avert with a sprog is no longer a rarity.

  20. пёЏRoman Viagra Review Enhance Sexual Stamina пёЏ Blood flow enhancement helps increase the quality of your erection and even The National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine has said using Ginkgo Biloba can help fight issues in the bedroom.
    65 MB 00 03 32 16K.
    We hope you liked this article.

  21. The answer is – this one.
    The interaction of substances of these drugs will reduce your blood pressure, which will lead to serious consequences.
    Summing up, we advise you not to risk your health.

  22. For more information about Travel Link, visit siriusxm.
    The plant prevents the formation of malignant cells, gives energy and vivacity, improves the complexion; Argier Hawaiian rose raises tone, activates the central nervous system, has a slight psychotropic effect; Wild Yams relieves fatigue and headache during menopause, suppresses the frequency of hot flashes.
    Viagra is typically used to treat erectile dysfunction the well-known and common condition affecting around 50 of men aged 40-70 years old.

  23. A good friend told me about Viagra Connect and I tried it.
    Let s get one thing clear, this 5 million Gold Coast five bedroom, five bathroom single family home is freakin incredible in every way.
    Therefore, today it is profitable to buy high-quality Indian generics in reliable online stores.

  24. Viagra is produced in different dosages and has many contraindications, so to prescribe these pills should only be a doctor.
    1 to 15, Viagra’s sildenafil-based generics in the lineup.
    This is maximum erection time.

  25. Even if they do, their action is usually mild and short-lived.
    It’s enough time to get rid of potency problems once and for all.
    COVID-19 coronavirus what is shielding and who needs it.

  26. You can likewise appreciate price cuts, extremely quick delivery therefore lots of other advantages online shoppers delight in.
    The future may be brighter than you think.
    Contradictions to the reception of Sialis.

  27. Photo Boss Royal Viagra.
    It is used with low amounts, low vitality and reduced sperm motility.
    Since the joint use of sildenafil and q-blockers can lead to symptomatic hypotension in some sensitive patients, the drug Viagra should be carefully prescribed to patients taking z-blockers see.

  28. The correct dose depends on your health condition.
    Unknown No interaction information available.
    The exact cost depends on the price policy of a pharmacy.

  29. Once you ve swallowed one pill, it may take up to 60 minutes to take full effect and this may last for up to 4 hours.
    In this topic 0 replies, 1 participant, last update vianateferxay 1 year, 2 months ago.
    The rate at which generic cialis is doing research for some of the diseases that are ailing the nation is amazing.

  30. Pingback: Viagra 25 mg cost
  31. Pingback: Viagra 130mg nz
  32. Pingback: cheap Cialis 10 mg
  33. But united winter Misha fell ill, and his contingency worsened. They began to purloin tests, viagra online and families reported a disconcerting and distressing diagnosis – dangerous lymphoblastic leukemia. At first, the parents could not confidence in that this had happened to their son, to them.

  34. Pingback: order arimidex 1mg
  35. Hi there just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The words in your post seem to be running off the screen in Safari. I’m not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with browser compatibility but I figured I’d post to let you know. The style and design look great though! Hope you get the issue solved soon. Thanks

  36. It’s appropriate time to make some plans for the future and it’s time to
    be happy. I have read this post and if I could I wish to suggest you few interesting
    things or suggestions. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article.
    I desire to read more things about it!

  37. Pingback: buy atarax 10 mg
  38. Pingback: rxtrust pharm
  39. Pingback: cheap buspar 10mg
  40. viagra generic availability sildenafil citrate malegra 50mg
    viagra commercial actress
    buy viagra online usa

  41. generic viagra uk next day delivery
    viagra coupons 2017
    levitra vs cialis vs viagra

  42. generic viagra online pharmacy usa
    viagra generico espaГ±a contrareembolso
    viagra super active plus online

  43. cialis vs viagra reviews
    viagra side effects skin rash
    herbal viagra side effects

  44. using viagra reddit
    generic viagra soft tabs reviews
    viagra commercial girl 2014

  45. como se debe tomar una pastilla de viagra
    viagra price cvs
    buy pfizer brand viagra online

  46. Pingback: buy viagra online
  47. pfizer brand viagra 100mg review
    viagra generic availability sildenafil citrate
    75% off coupons on viagra

  48. Pingback: casodex nz
  49. pfizer brand viagra 100mg uk
    viagra coupons meijer
    generic viagra available in us pharmacy

  50. Pingback: ceftin for sale
  51. Pingback: buy celebrex 100mg